How Can We Help You?

Maintain your peace of mind knowing that our
insurance professionals have your back.

Auto Icon

Auto

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Home Icon

Home

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Business Icon

Business

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Life Icon

Life

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Workers's Comp. Icon

Workers's Comp.

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Contractors Icon

Contractors

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote

Why Choose Shirer Insurance Services?

Shirer Insurance Services offers a wide variety of insurance choices from reputable insurance carriers in Indiana, Illinois & Michigan. Our relationships with these insurance companies allow us to shop for a policy that meets your coverage needs and your budget. Our goal is to offer you advice, extensive choices, and superior customer service.

If you’re looking for an independent insurance agent you can trust, contact us today for a complete evaluation of your insurance needs. We’ll make recommendations on what coverage is right for you, and answer any questions you have. Look up our many 5 star reviews and give us a chance!

Instant Insurance Quote

In a hurry? Get a quote on your insurance policy instantly.

Get Started!
Get an instant quote today!

We are here for you
Get started with
a quote

Featured Carriers

American Collectors Logo
AmTrust Logo
Arlington Roe Logo
Auto Owners Logo
Celina Logo
Chubb Logo
CNA Surety Logo
Foremost Logo
Great American Insurance Logo
GUARD Logo
Hagerty Logo
Indiana Farmers Logo
ISU Logo
Liberty Mutual Logo
National General Logo
Nationwide Logo
Openly Logo
Progressive Logo
Rockford Mutual Logo
Safeco Logo
Society Logo
The Hartford Logo

What Clients Say

After waiting a week for my long-time insurance broker to find a new policy, Mike got me covered in 30 minutes flat. It was so easy! Thanks, Mike!

-Nathan Reeder

Fantastic service. Michael has saved us a ton of money with better coverage. Switched Auto, home and water craft to him. Highly recommended.

-Pat Savell

Mike Hayes was very knowledgeable and helpful with my business general liability and workmans comp insurance- I've found my future business insurer and couldn't be more satisfied!!

-mAd hAdDeR

Working with Mike and the Shirer Insurance team has been a smooth, dependable experience. They’re quick to respond, incredibly knowledgeable, and always professional. What sets them apart is how genuinely invested they are in our success. Whether it’s a policy update or a quick question, they handle everything with speed,...

-Jacqueline velasco

Friendly customer service! Shirer Insurance does all the work for you in comparing insurance rates. I highly recommend!

-Joanna Nikolopoulos

I had an amazing experience working with Beckie Hayes! From the very beginning, she was incredibly kind, patient, and knowledgeable about all the different coverages. She took the time to walk me through everything, making sure I fully understood my options. What could’ve been a confusing and stressful process ended...

-Anais Picazzo

I’ve worked with Mari on my home and auto insurance policies for a couple years—she’s certainly the most thorough and also the most pleasant insurance agent I’ve ever worked with. She is knowledgeable, professional, and goes the extra mile not only to ensure her clients have the right coverage, but...

-J Miller

🛡️ Huge thanks to Mike at Shirer Insurance! He got me set up with classic car insurance — top-notch service, super knowledgeable, and incredibly efficient. On top of all that, just an all-around awesome guy to work with. If you need coverage, definitely check out Shirer Insurance — they’ll take...

-Jon Robinson

Back in May of this year, a young lady made an improper oncoming left-hand turn right in front of me, resulting in a T-bone collision. I was so grateful that neither of us were injured, but I honestly didn’t know what to do as I knew a tow truck was...

-Brenda R

Blog

July 10, 2025

6 Ways to Safeguard Your Pool

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

©2025. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites